OINNet — Online International News Network

Expert witness in Letby trial barred from practice during second prosecution case

Prof Peter Hindmarsh gave evidence in Birmingham parents' conviction while excluded from treating patients, raising questions about expert witness disclosure.

Authenticity Score: 77/100 across 1 source(s). First reported: 2026-11-21T08:00:52Z. Updated: 2026-11-22T01:00:41Z.

A doctor who testified against convicted nurse Lucy Letby was simultaneously barred from clinical practice yet continued as an expert witness in another prosecution. The Guardian revealed Prof Peter Hindmarsh was excluded from treating patients in March 2023 during his involvement in a second case.

Verified Key Facts

Prof Peter Hindmarsh, who provided expert testimony that contributed to Lucy Letby's conviction, was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 while serving as an expert witness in a separate prosecution, The Guardian has reported.

Hindmarsh played a key role in the conviction of two Birmingham parents whose son died following a diabetes episode. His exclusion from treating patients occurred during the Letby trial proceedings, yet he was subsequently instructed as an expert witness in the Birmingham case.

The disclosure raises questions about the duty to inform courts and defendants regarding expert witnesses' professional standing during criminal proceedings.

Corroborating Sources